This topic contains 15 replies, has 9 voices, and was last updated by 
JudyR 2 months ago.
-
Posts
-
This started out as just a half-hearted messy loose attempt at practicing on my new Arches CP, but when I started putting the tree trunks and branches in, it started to actually look like a painting so I started trying a bit harder. I wasn’t paying close attention to the video in the beginning so I didn’t get the best tree shapes. I went a little crazy as usual with the branches..less would’ve been more…my brush just wouldn’t stop painting them! In the end I kind of liked it. 🙂
-
A lovely windy feel to the painting, Lora. I’m just a little concerned that it appears to be blowing in two directions at once. I’d be tempted to split it down the middle for two smaller paintings.
Joy
-
Thank you, Joy. If you’re talking about the tree branches reaching toward each other in the center, that’s actually how it was in Peter Woolley’s painting that I copied. I actually chose this to do because that’s my favorite part. I felt like that’s just how the branches were growing, but that doesn’t seem too realistic. I just don’t think it’s meant to be too realistic, more artsy maybe. His painting had a whimsical feel to it to me and that’s why I chose to try it. But I do understand what you’re saying. This one is just a bit of fun. 😀
-
-
Nice colors and shadows.
Paula
-
Thanks, Paula! I chose colors pretty close to what Peter used in his version because I really thought it added to the whimsical autumn feel of the scene. 😀
-
Nicely done 🙂 reminds me of Winnie the Pooh’s blustery day!
-
Awwww thanks, K8! That’s the best compliment I could get as I loved reading Pooh books as a child! I felt like this scene looked like a children’s book illustration, also. Great minds think alike! 😀
-
-
Lovely and free. Nice and expressive. Well done
Take time to look and make sure you see.
-
Thanks, Brad! It turned out a lot better than I thought it would lol.
-
-
Lovely painting Lora! I’ve seen this video but didn’t attempt it myself. Peter makes it look easy 🙂
-
Thanks, Alex! You’re right Peter always makes it look so easy!
-
-
Lovely Lora, floaty and breezy, fresh and not over worked, nothing more to say, splendid!
-
Thanks, Annette! I had fun painting this and had to force myself to stop adding branches and falling leaves! So easy to overwork a painting!
-
-
Charming painting and just full of life. I don’t mean to be critical but its a little too symmetrical which could be fixed by matting it off center. Its too late but I would make the path somewhat wider at the entrance and angle towars the horizon. These are composition ( rule of thirds and S shape) suggestions only because the execution is great.
-
Thanks for the positive comments, David. As for the criticism…like I explained in the title of my post and in a comment above, this is from a video by UK artist Peter Woolley, so he is the one who broke the composition rules. I know about the rules, but I’ve also read that sometimes it’s ok to break them. Usually I don’t like symmetry in paintings, but this painting of Peter’s just really appealed to me because it seemed whimsical and fun for some reason. I like how the trees seem to be reaching towards each other even though that’s not realistic. Sometimes I like artsy, nonrealistic paintings, but not always. This was one of those that appealed to me so thought I’d try it for practice on my new paper. Just a bit of fun. 🙂
-
Lora, I think this is well painted, colorful, and whimsical. Three factors that make viewing it a pleasure. I agree, all paintings don’t have to conform to all the rules (who makes them up anyway–some engineer with no imagination ;)! No offense engineers!!) Personally, I do try to apply them to a composition, but sometimes you just have to have a bit of fun.
You must be logged in to reply to this topic.